Dr Victoria Mutiso murder case: Lawyers withdraw as 5 accused plead not guilty afresh

The Five accused persons in the Dr Victoria Mutiso murder case when they appeared in Miliman High Court.PHOTO/@ODPP_KE/X

The Dr Victoria Mutiso murder case took a fresh turn on Tuesday after five accused persons pleaded not guilty to murder charges, while lawyers representing three of them withdrew from the proceedings.

The five accused, politician Rose Mbithe, her daughter Angela Mulwa, her son Chris Mulwa, Police Constable Elijah Kibelion Kimoi and Kimutai Maritim, alias Kim, were charged afresh after the cases were consolidated into a single case file.

The development followed earlier court directions for the accused persons to appear physically for plea-taking after proceedings involving the separate files had been delayed. The consolidation was subsequently placed before Justice Alexander Muteti.

All five accused pleaded not guilty to the murder charge, according to a statement by the Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (ODPP).

The prosecution was led by Deputy Director of Public Prosecutions Jalson Makori, assisted by Senior Assistant Director of Public Prosecutions Wangui Gichui, Assistant Director of Public Prosecutions Pauline Muthuri and Prosecution Counsel Lydia Chelogoi.

Lawyers withdraw

The biggest development during Tuesday’s proceedings was the withdrawal of defence counsel representing the first, second and third accused persons, Mbithe, Angela Mulwa and Chris Mulwa.

The ODPP said the lawyers โ€œsubsequently stepped down from the matterโ€, citing what they described as โ€œmiscommunication and concerns about the conduct of the case.โ€

The withdrawal came as the accused persons prepared to challenge their continued detention through bail applications.

Separate reporting from the proceedings identified the lawyers as Danstan Omari, Cliff Ombeta, Shadrack Wambui and Martina Swiga, who told the High Court they no longer wished to act for the three accused persons. The court was also informed that the accused had issues they wanted to discuss with their legal teams.

The withdrawal does not amount to a finding on the murder allegations against the three accused persons, which remain before the court.

The late Dr Victoria Nthunya Mutiso.PHOTO/@DCI_Kenya/X
The late Dr Victoria Nthunya Mutiso.PHOTO/@DCI_Kenya/X

Five deny charge

The fresh plea-taking brings the five accused into one consolidated murder case.

Maritim became the fifth person to face the murder charge after the ODPP approved his prosecution on September 23. The ODPP said he would be charged alongside Mbithe, Angela Mulwa, Chris Mulwa and Kimoi.

The consolidation means the five accused will now face the murder proceedings together, although each remains entitled to defend the allegations against them individually.

The plea of not guilty means the accused have denied the charge. Any question of criminal responsibility will ultimately be determined through the judicial process.

Bail hearing set

The case will next come before Justice Muteti on October 6, 2026, for the hearing of the bail application.

The ODPP said the matter would be mentioned on that date โ€œfor the hearing of the bail application.โ€

The bail proceedings will be the next significant stage after Tuesday’s fresh plea-taking and the withdrawal of counsel representing the first three accused.

Reporting from the proceedings said the court was yet to hear the substantive bail applications when the lawyers withdrew. The prosecution had sought additional time to respond to issues raised in relation to the applications.

ODPP Office in Nairobi.PHOTO/RonnyTV
ODPP Office in Nairobi.PHOTO/RonnyTV

Case moves forward

Dr Victoria Nthunya Mutiso was killed in Nairobi on July 29, 2026. Five people are now facing murder charges in connection with her death, following the ODPP’s decision to prosecute Maritim as the fifth accused.

The prosecution alleges links between the accused and the killing, but those allegations have not been proved in court. All five accused have pleaded not guilty.

The immediate focus is now on the October 6 bail proceedings, as the first three accused seek new legal representation following the withdrawal of their previous lawyers.

The case remains at the pre-trial stage, and the court has yet to determine the guilt or innocence of any of the five accused.