Premier League clubs consider legal action against Manchester City over financial breaches

A photo collage of the Etihad Stadium, home of Premier Club Manchester City

Several Premier League clubs are considering legal action against Manchester City after an independent panel found the club guilty of 114 of 115 alleged financial rule breaches.

Arsenal, Manchester United, Liverpool and Tottenham Hotspur are among the clubs reported to have preserved their rights to seek compensation for financial losses they believe may have resulted from City’s alleged breaches.

The potential claims could involve millions of pounds in lost revenue, including prize money, Champions League qualification income, league-position bonuses and other commercial opportunities.

Reports indicate that successful claims by the affected clubs could collectively be worth more than £200 million, although the figure is an estimate and no compensation has yet been awarded.

The development follows reports that the independent commission has upheld 114 of the 115 charges brought against City by the Premier League.

The charges relate largely to the period between the 2009/10 and 2017/18 seasons. The Premier League had accused City of failing to provide accurate financial information, providing incomplete details concerning player and manager payments, breaching financial regulations and failing to cooperate with the league’s investigation.

Statement of transfer journalist Fabrizio Romano on Premier League clubs weighing compensation against Manchester City. PHOTO/https://www.facebook.com/fabrizioromanoherewego
Statement of transfer journalist Fabrizio Romano on Premier League clubs weighing compensation against Manchester City. PHOTO/Screengrab by Ronny TV/https://www.facebook.com/fabrizioromanoherewego

City have consistently denied wrongdoing and are expected to appeal the findings. The club has also stressed that the Premier League process is not yet complete.

“The Premier League process remains ongoing, with significant elements to be completed, and subject to strict confidentiality,” City said in a statement reported by BBC Sport. “As such Manchester City FC’s position remains consistent with the club’s statement of February 2023.”

Why clubs could seek compensation

The potential legal claims centre on whether City’s alleged breaches gave the club an unfair competitive and financial advantage that affected other Premier League teams.

Clubs could argue that their final league positions were affected and that this resulted in lost prize money or bonuses.

There could also be claims relating to qualification for European competitions. A club that believes it missed out on the Champions League because of City’s position in the table could seek to establish the financial value of that missed opportunity.

The Independent reported that Manchester United finished second behind City in the 2011/12 and 2017/18 Premier League seasons, while Liverpool were runners-up in 2013/14. City qualified for the Champions League throughout the period covered by the case.

However, any club bringing a claim would still have to demonstrate a clear connection between City’s rule breaches and its own financial loss.

Paul Stothard, a partner at Norton Rose Fulbright, told the Guardian that clubs seeking compensation would need to prove how City’s breaches affected their ability to compete and establish the value of any loss.

Four clubs had protected their position

Arsenal, Manchester United, Liverpool and Tottenham are reported to have taken steps to preserve their potential rights to compensation under Section W of the Premier League rules.

The move was important because of legal time limits surrounding potential claims.

The Independent reported that the four clubs had effectively protected their position before the relevant limitation period expired, while other clubs have also sought legal advice over whether they could pursue claims.

That means the latest development does not automatically translate into lawsuits against City. The clubs must still establish the legal basis for their claims, demonstrate financial losses and potentially wait for City’s appeal to be concluded.

Everton-Burnley case provides precedent

A recent Premier League case involving Everton and Burnley has added another dimension to the potential claims against City.

In June 2026, Burnley secured a £35 million compensation award against Everton after arguing that Everton’s breach of the league’s Profitability and Sustainability Rules had contributed to their relegation from the Premier League.

Everton has appealed the decision.

The case has nevertheless provided a recent example of one Premier League club seeking financial compensation from another over the sporting and economic consequences of a financial-rule breach.

Lawyers quoted in reports about the Manchester City case have suggested that the Burnley-Everton decision could make potential claims against City easier to contemplate, although the circumstances of each case would have to be considered separately.

What happens next?

Manchester City are expected to challenge the independent panel’s findings, meaning the legal situation is far from settled.

The Premier League has not yet publicly announced the sanctions to be imposed on City, while the club’s appeal could affect both the eventual punishment and any subsequent compensation claims.

Ouside the Etiha Stadium, home of Manchester City. PHOTO/https://www.facebook.com/fabrizioromanoherewego
Outside the Etihad Stadium, home of Manchester City. PHOTO/https://www.facebook.com/fabrizioromanoherewego

Possible sporting and financial sanctions have been widely discussed, but no final punishment has been announced.

The original Premier League case began in February 2023 after a four-year investigation. The hearing before the independent commission took place behind closed doors in 2024 and lasted about 12 weeks.

The case covers a period in which City won multiple domestic trophies and established themselves as one of the dominant teams in English football.

For the clubs considering compensation, the central question will now be whether they can demonstrate that the breaches directly caused identifiable financial losses.

If such claims proceed, the dispute could therefore extend beyond the Premier League’s disciplinary process and develop into a separate series of legal battles involving some of the biggest clubs in English football.